Tim Buckley Owen Link charges - beware of what you wish for...
Jinfo Blog

Wednesday, 22nd September 2010 Sign in to MyJinfo or create an account be able to star items Printable version Subscribe via RSS to get updates as soon as Blog items are added

By Tim Buckley Owen


Legal uncertainties continue to dog content aggregators on both sides of the Atlantic. As participants in FreePint's current News Needs & Preferences survey ponder their responses, a couple of recent developments may provide food for thought.

If the Newspaper Licensing Agency (NLA) wins the right to charge for links made to its members' publications, that could open the way for aggregators to send actual content to users instead of simply URLs. The suggestion is made in paidContent:UK during an interview with Meltwater chief executive Jørn Lyseggen, who is currently in dispute with the NLA over links alone - and it seems to have taken him by surprise (http://digbig.com/5bckfn). It's a further twist in an affair that actually involves two parallel cases being pursued in the United Kingdom.

At the turn of this year, Meltwater referred the NLA's charging proposals to the Copyright Tribunal, which adjudicates on such matters (http://www.vivavip.com/go/e27632) - while the following May the NLA itself sought a definitive ruling in the High Court on whether its licence was legal or not (http://www.vivavip.com/go/e29171). According to paidContent:UK, the first High Court hearing is due in November, while the Copyright Tribunal isn't expected to start till next February.

Meanwhile, though, the NLA's High Court action is an interesting reflection on the fact that, although a number of cases have been brought over the last few years, there don't yet seem to be any definitive rulings. In the United States, Kimberley Isbell of the Citizen Media Law Project reaches the same view: no case has yet addressed the question of whether aggregators' activities are legal. She has been gathering together evidence on the current state of American law regarding aggregation - and it's complicated. Isbell identifies four different categories of aggregator (feed, specialty, user-created and blog) and two distinct issues: copyright, where fair dealing may apply; and hot news misappropriation, where a news provider might argue that an aggregator's republication of time-sensitive information damages the provider's business, although a defendant might counterclaim under the First Amendment to the US Constitution, which in principle safeguards the dissemination of truthful information about matters of public concern (http://digbig.com/5bckfq).

Information managers - the people who ultimately have to pay for much of this content, however sourced - may feel that they can do no more than stand waiting on the sidelines as the issues are fought out elsewhere. But they are actually the key players in the whole process, and they have an opportunity to make their voices heard. So what's the best outcome for safeguarding the creation of original content while ensuring its cost-effective dissemination? 'Free... Fee... Freemium' is the strapline for this year's FreePint News Needs & Preferences Survey (http://digbig.com/5bchet), and it's not too late to add your views.

« Blog

What's new at Jinfo?

Focus on Value Chain

Document the value chain, and transform the way you think about, manage and report on your product portfolio and your information service contributions to your organisation goals.

Focus on Value Chain

Focus on Risk Assessment

Risk assessment to gauge the ability of your services, team, portfolio and overall value to withstand stress is a required process for a healthy information department.

Focus on Risk Assessment

Benefit from our research

Our proven processes, resources and guidance will help your team make the shift from transaction centre to strategic asset.


Designed around the most common challenges and pain points for time- and resource-strapped information teams

Supercharge remote productivity and value
Holistic content portfolio management
Future-proof your information service
Executive-ready communications


A tailored overview of our research and active discussion with your Jinfo analyst.


Measure your starting point to articulate your strengths and set priorities for future improvements. Assessments gauge risk, capacity, value and more.

Read case studies, and start the conversation:

Consulting benefits

Connect your team with the practical tools, original research and expertise to build and support information strategy in your organisation.

A Jinfo Subscription gives access to all Content (articles, reports, webinars) and Community.

Subscription benefits